Bad Bunny Wins Summary Judgment on Key Theory in Reggaeton Copyright Lawsuit
Browne v. Donalds, No. 2:21-cv-02840-AB-AJR (C.D. Cal.)
For five years, a single lawsuit has hung over reggaeton. Jamaican production duo Steely & Clevie claimed that the genre’s signature “dembow” rhythm, the percussion pulse that drives countless hits, originated with their 1989 instrumental “Fish Market.” Their consolidated case swept in roughly 1,800 songs by more than 100 artists, including Bad Bunny, Karol G, Daddy Yankee, Drake, Pitbull, Justin Bieber, and Anitta.
On September 1, 2026, U.S. District Judge André Birotte Jr. granted the Rimas Defendants’ motion for reconsideration, vacated his prior denial of summary judgment, and granted defendants’ partial motion for summary judgment on plaintiffs’ selection-and-arrangement theory. Kenneth Freundlich of Freundlich Law, lead counsel for Bad Bunny and the Rimas Defendants, argued the motion.
A rare reversal
Motions for reconsideration seldom succeed. This one did. In July, Judge Birotte had denied the parties’ cross-motions for partial summary judgment, concluding that the threshold question of protectability involved factual disputes for a jury. That ruling cleared the way for a trial that defendants warned would require discovery into nearly 2,000 songs and could stretch on for years.
The defense asked the Court to take a closer look at what, exactly, the plaintiffs claimed to own.
One work, not several
Freundlich pointed to Clevie Browne’s own testimony indicating that the two-bar pattern presented in the complaint as “Fish Market” was drawn from separate portions of the song. The defense further showed that the timbale loop plaintiffs identified as protectable appears in a different recording, “Pounder (Dub Mix II),” and that while plaintiffs own the Pounder sound recording, they do not own its underlying composition.
Judge Birotte agreed that this was fatal to the theory. He held that plaintiffs had not identified any single copyrighted work containing the selection and arrangement they sought to enforce, and that a plaintiff cannot construct the work it is suing over from fragments of several separate works. He further held that identifying the work at issue is a threshold question for the Court rather than the jury, and that the scope of a claimed copyright cannot shift as litigation proceeds. The ruling extends to the other defendants who joined the motion.
Why it matters
The decision reaffirms a basic but important principle: copyright protects an original work, not a combination of elements gathered from different sources. For artists and labels facing infringement claims built on rhythms, grooves, and genre conventions, the ruling underscores that a plaintiff must first identify a specific copyrighted work that actually contains what it claims to own.
“The court has now confirmed what the defendants have maintained from the outset: that copyright protects an original, single work, not a combination of elements assembled from several different songs for the purpose of a lawsuit,” said Freundlich. “This is a significant result not only for Rimas and Bad Bunny, but for the many artists who were swept into this case, and for the integrity of copyright law itself.”
What comes next
The ruling resolves plaintiffs’ broad composition theory but not the entire case.
Order Granting Motion for Reconsideration, Dkt. 866
Coverage: Rolling Stone, Billboard, New York Times, Bloomberg Law, Marketplace

